Thursday, January 2, 2014
Think Faith: New Blog
I invite you to join me at my new blog "Think Faith."
think-faith.blogspot.com
It started bugging me that while "Flee Naked" may be a catchy name that makes people take more than a glance, to get the name I was basically prooftexting. The idea comes from Mark 14:51-52 where a young man escapes capture by slipping out of his robe and running off naked. My take on it was that there are many things in this world, even good things (like the young man's clothing) that can be used to hold us captive to sin. We need to be willing to let go of these things and escape from sin, even if that means embarassment or awkwardness.
Now, that is all well and good, except that I'm not actually sure that is the point Mark had in mind when he recorded it.While "fleeing naked" may be a principle you can argue from other places in Scripture, THIS verse isn't addressing that issue.
There is a danger when we allow ourselves to read our own ideas into a text from The Bible. This is called, "reader response." Reader response is a method of interpretation when you ask, "What does this mean to me?" Where as the important thing to get from reading Scripture is, "What did the author intend to convey?"
See, if we stretch the text beyond it's intended meaning, we may not drift off into heresy right away, but we set a dangerous habit of believing our own ideas/feelings over what God has said. Often times we do this with verses that can be pulled out of context to be used as a clever little one-liner to get across a point or to encourage during certain circumstances.
Sometimes this isn't necesserily a big deal because the idea we are reading into the text is actually a sound Biblical principle found elsewhere .. but our prooftexting says it more cleverly. Hence "Flee Naked."
Like I said, not necessarily a big deal, except that it sets a precedent and creates a habit that is bad Bible interpretation that can cause all sorts of trouble when the principle is NOT something found elsewhere in the Bible, and we basically start putting words in God's mouth, claiming He has said or meant things which He never said or meant.
We do not need to bend and stretch The Bible to say certain things or sound a certain way, especially taking verses out of context and creating a meaning in them to say things that other verses already say instead. The Truth of God's Word is clear and robustly upheld when you examine the evidence from logic, reason, science, and history.
God has not required us to leave our brain behind as we follow Him. Indeed in Matthew 22 we are commanded to love the Lord with all of our MIND (v37). The Christian faith is not blind faith. Is is a thoughtful and logical faith.
So join me as I think about faith.
think-faith.blogspot.com
https://www.facebook.com/pages/Think-Faith/194474967302049
Friday, December 13, 2013
You are Unworthy but Worth It
At a recent meeting with other youth pastors, the conversation turned to the issue of self-injury. We were all pretty saddened by how wide-spread this is among teenagers. It seems like depression, anxiety and anger rule the day with so many young adults these days. The Gospel of Jesus Christ is the #1 thing I want to impart to young people I meet. The #2 thing is this: You are NOT your feelings! Both of these ideas taken together should be a warm blanket to the soul of anyone, but even among "church kids" we see large amounts of depression, anger and even cutting. I can't help but wonder how many of our young people actually understand and believe these 2 truths.
Our culture teaches us that our worth and value as people is based on how we feel, or what people think about us, or how we feel about what other people think about us. It's all wrapped up in the idea of self-esteem and belonging, and it is tearing people apart. I have seen several well-intended people share things on social media basically saying something along the lines of "Don't pay attention to people who make fun of you on the outside because you are beautiful on the inside." Is that supposed to mean that if they just knew "the real you" they would like you? All that does is instead of people judging you based on the outside, now they judge you based on the inside. And I hate to break it to you, but people are jerks. There are going to be people who mock and hate the "inside" as well as the outside. Because it's not about you. It's about them. They are jerks.
Your worth or value is NOT based on what other people think about you, inside or out. And that even means it is not based on what you think about yourself.
Please read through everything I say, because the first point is gonna be a bit hard to swallow.
You are not awesome.
According to the Bible, the Word of Almighty God who created you and knows you better than you know yourself, you are a sinful, selfish, pride-filled sinner who's wicked heart seeks to be the ruler of your own little world instead of obeying the holy, righteous and loving God who gave you life. Because of this you are not deserving of warm, happy thoughts and pep talks about individual worth and value. You deserve punishment for your crimes against the Creator who not only gave you life but continually blesses you each day despite your rebellion against Him.
But guess what ... so does everyone else! Let that one sink in.
You're not alone in this. We're all in the same boat. All those people who want to down on you and tell you you're no good ... they're no better. They are wretched little sinners just like the rest of us, so why care what they think?
So where's the warm blanket? This is feeling kinda cold.
Your worth or value is not based on how you feel or what others think. It is based on God. What He says, and what He thinks about you. And despite your sin, He still loved you enough to pay the ultimate price. Jesus underwent mocking, beating, and death. That punishment you deserved for your sin, He took that for you. Not because you are awesome, but because He loves you. Not because you deserved it, but because that's just who He is. A Savior. We look for someone to tell us that we are good and we are valuable and that we are worthy. But out heart knows better.
I once heard a pastor say (and I use it with my students at church), "It's ok to not be ok, but Jesus isn't going to leave you there."
No, you're not perfect and you're not "worthy", but guess what... He didn't say you had to be, and the mess He found you in, ... He's willing to clean it up for you. It may not happen overnight, and it may not always be fun ... but that wretched, selfish, little sinner He rescued on the Cross, He's going to transform that person into a son or a daughter of God, the King.
He pulls us out of the mud and much and filth of our broken, sinful hearts. He cleans us up and turns us into something new. Something better. We may not have been worthy, but He thought we were worth it.
So you're not perfect ... not even close ... so what? Your value isn't found in other people or even how you feel. It's found in the fact that God finds you valuable. You are valuable to Him, and nothing anyone else thinks or feels about you (including yourself) can take that away.
I grew up skinny, geeky and awkward. I was a target for every variety of bully around. I know there can be times it doesn't feel very hopeful. I know the pain is real and the feelings can seem overwhelming. But remember #2: Your feelings do not define you! Feelings come and go. Your hope is not found in feelings. It is found in knowings. Hope holds on when all reason says to let go, because we KNOW God is faithful and that He loves us, even when no one else seems to. Even when we don't love ourselves. Your hope is not based on the opinions of others. It's not even based on your own opinion. It's based on God.
Monday, December 9, 2013
Uncomfortable Conversations
Could it be that we are awkward talking to non-believers, not because they (or their possible objections) make us unconfortable but because we are uncomfortable talking about Jesus Christ?
Think about it for a moment. What are the things we seem to have no problem talking to anyone about? A recent movie or TV show we watched. Something that happened at work or school. The slow guy in the fast lane on the highway. A recent sports event. A concert we went to. A vacation we took. Some cute or rediculous thing our child or younger sibling or friend did. I'm sure we could all keep coming up with more.
What do these things have in common? It can't be shared interest, at least not primarily. We will talk about some of these things even if the other person is visibly not interested, whether a complete stranger or close family. There are just some things we want to talk about.
And I think that is the key: stuff we want to talk about.
If you are excited enough, passionate enough, annoyed enough or care enough, you will talk to anyone about whatever it is.
Typically, when asked why they don't share their faith more, most Christians usually respond with something like, "I don't know what to say," or "I'm afraid they'll ask questions or have objections I can't answer." But that doesn't seem to stop us from talking about anything else.
When was the last time someone was uneasy talking abou the Cowboys because the other person might come back with criticism of Romo? ..... ok, bad example .... but you get what I mean! If we enjoyed a concert over the weekend, we don't hesitate to talk to our co-workers or classmates about it just because they may not be fans of that type of music. We don't shy away from talking about all sorts of things.
When was the last time someone was uneasy talking abou the Cowboys because the other person might come back with criticism of Romo? ..... ok, bad example .... but you get what I mean! If we enjoyed a concert over the weekend, we don't hesitate to talk to our co-workers or classmates about it just because they may not be fans of that type of music. We don't shy away from talking about all sorts of things.
We simply do not use the same excuses with other things that we use with talking about Christ.
I think about the guy born blind in John 9. Jesus puts mud on his eyes and tells him to go wash it off.
When he does, he can see. Challenged and questioned by the religious authorities of his day his simple response is, "I don't know about that, I just know that I was blind and now I see." (paraphrased)
When he does, he can see. Challenged and questioned by the religious authorities of his day his simple response is, "I don't know about that, I just know that I was blind and now I see." (paraphrased)
We see this with people Jesus heals all over the place. They run off and tell everyone what happened. They didn't wait to take a class on Biblical doctrine or apologetics or methods of evangelism or read books on tough questions by skeptics. They just went and said, "look what He did!"
Are we interested enough in what Jesus has done for us to want to tell other people about it? If not ... why not?
Thursday, December 5, 2013
Fundamentalism vs Apologetics
As
I mentioned previously, a friend claimed that apologetics seems to be
at odds with fundamentalism. Through the course of the conversation we
rabbit trailed and meandered through some other areas and
miscommunications and even had trouble coming to an agreed on the definition
of fundamentalism and the nature of faith. I thought it would be good
to do my best to have a clear and concise explanation of my position on
this.
Fundamentalism was explained in a previous blog article.
The
best I could grasp it, the idea posed seemed to be that fundamentalism
is based on faith and faith can't be based on evidence or it ceases to
be faith. Since apologetics is the use of evidence, therefore,
fundamentalists (like myself) would be inconsistent to "do" apologetics.
That may not be exactly what he was getting at, but I have heard this sort of idea before.
Christian Apologetics as was being used in our conversation I think is best summed up
as "a reasoned support of Biblical truth using extra-biblical evidence."
Faith
is a tricky thing and a point of much debate in theological and
philosophical circles. My friend seemed to indicate (and I have heard this way of thinking before) that the very nature of faith is believing something in a vacuum of evidence (my words).I operate under the definition that Christian faith is
reasonable trust in beliefs that have been demonstrated to be
trustworthy.
Jesus loves me, this I know, for the Bible tells me so ... yes, AND because there is other extra-biblical reasons to believe that to be true.
The idea of apologetics
comes from the urging we have to be ready and able to give a defense
or explanation for the ideas, beliefs, principles, etc. that you adhere to.
"But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts, and always be ready to give a defense to everyone who asks you a reason for the hope that is in you, with meekness and fear."
Can extra-biblical sources serve as evidence for biblical truth?
A
reasoned argument for apologetics is that extra-biblical evidence is
not proof that determines the truth of the Bible, it is evidence that
describes
the truth of the Bible. God's Word is not dependent on our ability to
prove it to be true, however, since God created the world and everything
in it, we should expect to find other evidences that agree with the
Bible but which are not specifically from the Bible.
An analogy would be a crime. Say I am a citizen deemed to have impeachable
character and generally considered by all to be honest and trustworthy
(we're just pretending), and I stop a crime in progress. From my vantage
point I saw the entire thing from the beginning until I stepped in. I saw
the victim. I saw the perpetrator, who happens to also live down the street from me. I heard what was said, and
immediately after the criminal fled, I was able to record the entire
thing in exquisite detail in my journal. Now, my testimony alone may be
enough to convince a jury and convict the criminal. Does that mean that
the police shouldn't get fingerprints and check security cameras and
check with other witnesses? Is the truth of my testimony dependent on other evidence being gathered? Does the use of
these other evidences somehow undermine the strength of my testimony?
Of course not. Those other evidences corroborate and lend support to the
truth of the primary testimony given, but they have no bearing on whether it is actually true, maybe just whether or not a person will find it more believable.
In
the same way, apologetics lends support and additional corroboration to
the testimony of scripture, but scripture is not dependent on
apologetics to be true or authoritative.
Since the
Bible is primarily our source for truth, what does it have to say about
using extra-biblical evidences (logic, reason, science, etc)?
God
created the world (Genesis 1 and 2), and we know that to at least some
degree knowledge about God is knowable from His creation (Romans
1:19-20).
While
creation alone cannot point to the specific knowledge of Jesus Christ
as the savior of the world on whom we must believe to receive
forgiveness of sin, it does demonstrate the existence of
God and certain qualities about Him and about us.
We
are commanded to love the Lord not only with our hearts but also with
our minds (Matt 22:37). Our faith is not only one of love but also
entails a "sound mind" (2 Timothy 1:7). The whole point of the book of
Proverbs is about being wise and not foolish in your thinking. "A wise man will hear and increase learning, And a man of understanding will attain wise counsel" (1:5).
Jesus often used parables which involve use of logic and reason to explain a concept in a more mundane or relatable way so it can then be brought into the greater religious context. He didn't just quote the Torah.
Peter in Acts 2 lays out the case and makes a defense (apologetics) for the reason Jesus came and died (and rose again) and why they need to put their faith in Him.
Acts 17 says that Paul "reasoned" with the Jews in the synagogue.
Paul also makes frequent use of quoting other philosophers and sources, using people's own philosophies and traditions to help explain Christianity to them and make the case for Christ: http://biblethingsinbibleways.wordpress.com/2013/07/14/paul-and-his-use-of-greek-philosophy/.
What it gets down to is this: If something is true, we do not expect to find only 1 place where it is supported and demonstrated to be true. If it is true that you are an honest person, I do not just take your word for it ... though you saying so would be true. I can check with your spouse, family, friends, co-workers, bosses, classmates, and find out if you are indeed an honest person. Evidence outside of you supports a truth claim about you.
In the same way, since the Bible is true, it is only rational that other things in life would demonstrate and point to the truth found in the Bible. And this is indeed what we see, and making use of those other evidences found in extra-biblical realms of knowledge to point back to the ultimate truth of God found in the Bible is not only consistent with a fundamentalist worldview, but it is a prudent and wise thing to do.
Tuesday, December 3, 2013
Fundamentally Unashamed
I recently had a conversation with a friend on Facebook about whether or not apologetics is at odds with fundamentalism. This conversation started because of a link I shared about apologetics, and he knows I identify as a "fundamentalist" which he feels doesn't leave room for the use of apologetics (a reasoned defense of biblical truth using extra-biblical evidences).
I will address the supposed contradiction in another post, but I thought it best that I make clear what I am describing as "fundamentalism". I unashamedly embrace the label of "Christian fundamentalist".
Fundamentalism is defined in the general sense of adhering to a basic set of core beliefs. That could be described as a strong commitment to those beliefs which are "fundamental" to a particular belief system.
"Christian" fundamentalism then would be adhering to the basic beliefs which are "fundamental" to the teachings of Christianity.
I adhere to the fundamental teachings (basic core principles) of orthodox Christianity, therefore I am a "Christian Fundamentalist." Here is a quick summary of those beliefs: The Bible is the inerrant, infallible Word of God, mankind possesses a sinful nature and is in a state of rebellion against God, we cannot 'make-up for it' with good works, and only faith in the atoning work of Jesus Christ paid for through His death and resurrection can reconcile us to God, and those who continue in their rebellion against the just, holy and righteous God who gave them life will receive the deserved consequence for their sin (rebellion).
I would like to note that the cultural baggage of closed-minded bigotry and extreme judgmentalism that the word "fundamentalist" usually implies is not "fundamental" to neither the teachings of Christ nor the doctrines of orthodox Christianity. If people claiming to be or labelled to be "fundamentally christian" behaved themselves in such manners, they were in error and opposed to the clear teachings of Christ and the Bible. So, I am taking the word back and unashamedly claim to be a "Fundamentalist Christian."
Saturday, November 23, 2013
"It's More Surprising That Anything is Right At All"
A recent paper from a classmate of mine quoted Mark Martindale, a developmental biologist at the University of Hawaii in Honolulu. “At the turn of the twentieth century, embryologists drew what they saw.
But their microscopes stunk and they didn’t know about genes. Now we’re finally able to look closer, and we’re
finding that they’re often wrong. But if you think about the tools they
had, maybe it’s more surprising that anything is right at all.” (emphasis added)
The quote was from an article at Nature.com (http://www.nature.com/news/penis-worm-pokes-holes-in-evolutionary-dogma-1.11667.
The more I learn, the more this seems to be the case with all evolutionary assertions. Ideas and theories from 100+ years ago are clung to with a veracity that rivals the most sold out religious zealot, all the while more and more evidence is being discovered to undermine those ideas. Instead of re-examining the overall model, scientists just redraw the model, completely ignoring (or oblivious to) the possibility that the foundational idea was flawed to begin with. All the while they beat the drum of "science is an examination of the data wherever it leads." As long as it doesn't lead to somewhere we don't want to go.
When creationists say something does not fit with our model, we can rework the model because we have outside information which to compare and help inform of interpretations of the evidence: The Bible. Naturalistic science (claims) has no such external influence inherent to it and is supposed to be based entirely on the physical evidence at hand, though even a general look at science shows that the philosophies of the scientist necessarily play a large role in the process.
Occassionally it seems you get an honest one who will say, "I want to believe it, but the evidence just doesn't go there." Stephen J Gould admitted gradualism can't be shown from the evidence, so he scrapped that and pursued another theory, Punctuated Equilibrium. I would say that he did not go far enough and needed to scrap molecules-to-man evolution all together.
The fact is that no matter what new evidence is found or re-interpreted they continue to try and cram it into a model based on theories from others long ago who did not have the tools, techniques, and access to information that we do today. For some reason, the details gained since Darwin can be adjusted in reference to HOW evolution happened, but don't you dare try to say Darwin or his theory was wrong. It's almost like it would be "blasphemy". For them it is akin to a religion. The evolutuionary fundamentalist will no more consider the theory to be wrong than a religious fundamentalist would deny God. The difference is (aside from the fact God exists) is that we will admit it. They still claim to be "doing science". With most scientists seeming to cling to naturalism and materialism yet denying that a philosophical slant exists, I can't help but want to repeat the words of Martindale, "Maybe it’s more surprising that anything is right at all."
The quote was from an article at Nature.com (http://www.nature.com/news/penis-worm-pokes-holes-in-evolutionary-dogma-1.11667.
The more I learn, the more this seems to be the case with all evolutionary assertions. Ideas and theories from 100+ years ago are clung to with a veracity that rivals the most sold out religious zealot, all the while more and more evidence is being discovered to undermine those ideas. Instead of re-examining the overall model, scientists just redraw the model, completely ignoring (or oblivious to) the possibility that the foundational idea was flawed to begin with. All the while they beat the drum of "science is an examination of the data wherever it leads." As long as it doesn't lead to somewhere we don't want to go.
When creationists say something does not fit with our model, we can rework the model because we have outside information which to compare and help inform of interpretations of the evidence: The Bible. Naturalistic science (claims) has no such external influence inherent to it and is supposed to be based entirely on the physical evidence at hand, though even a general look at science shows that the philosophies of the scientist necessarily play a large role in the process.
Occassionally it seems you get an honest one who will say, "I want to believe it, but the evidence just doesn't go there." Stephen J Gould admitted gradualism can't be shown from the evidence, so he scrapped that and pursued another theory, Punctuated Equilibrium. I would say that he did not go far enough and needed to scrap molecules-to-man evolution all together.
The fact is that no matter what new evidence is found or re-interpreted they continue to try and cram it into a model based on theories from others long ago who did not have the tools, techniques, and access to information that we do today. For some reason, the details gained since Darwin can be adjusted in reference to HOW evolution happened, but don't you dare try to say Darwin or his theory was wrong. It's almost like it would be "blasphemy". For them it is akin to a religion. The evolutuionary fundamentalist will no more consider the theory to be wrong than a religious fundamentalist would deny God. The difference is (aside from the fact God exists) is that we will admit it. They still claim to be "doing science". With most scientists seeming to cling to naturalism and materialism yet denying that a philosophical slant exists, I can't help but want to repeat the words of Martindale, "Maybe it’s more surprising that anything is right at all."
“At
the turn of the twentieth century, embryologists drew what they saw.
But their microscopes stunk and they didn’t know about genes,”
Martindale says. “Now we’re finally able to look closer, and we’re
finding that they’re often wrong. But if you think about the tools they
had, maybe it’s more surprising that anything is right at all.” - See
more at:
http://crev.info/2012/11/three-new-fossil-finds-challenge-evolution/#sthash.68rg6BGu.tRwWmgB8.dpuf
“At
the turn of the twentieth century, embryologists drew what they saw.
But their microscopes stunk and they didn’t know about genes,”
Martindale says. “Now we’re finally able to look closer, and we’re
finding that they’re often wrong. But if you think about the tools they
had, maybe it’s more surprising that anything is right at all.” - See
more at:
http://crev.info/2012/11/three-new-fossil-finds-challenge-evolution/#sthash.68rg6BGu.tRwWmgB8.dpuf
“At
the turn of the twentieth century, embryologists drew what they saw.
But their microscopes stunk and they didn’t know about genes,”
Martindale says. “Now we’re finally able to look closer, and we’re
finding that they’re often wrong. But if you think about the tools they
had, maybe it’s more surprising that anything is right at all.” - See
more at:
http://crev.info/2012/11/three-new-fossil-finds-challenge-evolution/#sthash.68rg6BGu.tRwWmgB8.dpuf
“At
the turn of the twentieth century, embryologists drew what they saw.
But their microscopes stunk and they didn’t know about genes,”
Martindale says. “Now we’re finally able to look closer, and we’re
finding that they’re often wrong. But if you think about the tools they
had, maybe it’s more surprising that anything is right at all.” - See
more at:
http://crev.info/2012/11/three-new-fossil-finds-challenge-evolution/#sthash.68rg6BGu.tRwWmgB8.dpuf
“At
the turn of the twentieth century, embryologists drew what they saw.
But their microscopes stunk and they didn’t know about genes,”
Martindale says. “Now we’re finally able to look closer, and we’re
finding that they’re often wrong. But if you think about the tools they
had, maybe it’s more surprising that anything is right at all.” - See
more at:
http://crev.info/2012/11/three-new-fossil-finds-challenge-evolution/#sthash.68rg6BGu.tRwWmgB8.dpuf
Mark
Martindale, a developmental biologist at the University of Hawaii in
Honolulu. - See more at:
http://crev.info/2012/11/three-new-fossil-finds-challenge-evolution/#sthash.68rg6BGu.tRwWmgB8.dpuf
Mark
Martindale, a developmental biologist at the University of Hawaii in
Honolulu. - See more at:
http://crev.info/2012/11/three-new-fossil-finds-challenge-evolution/#sthash.68rg6BGu.tRwWmgB8.dpuf
Tuesday, November 19, 2013
Faith-Healing, Medicine and Freedom
I
recently read an article (linked below) regarding faith-healing
religious sects that deny medical care and the pain and deaths of
children that come as a result. The article focused on the changing of
laws that protects the parents of these children from charges of
negligence, manslaughter, etc. due to medical care being withheld on
religious grounds and consists of a string of heartbreaking stories with
links to find more.
I
see two issues going on here: (1) Religious Liberty, particularly the
right to it and the need for it to be protected, and (2) The
relationship between Faith and Medicine. I will address #2 first.
I
am personally saddened that many of the "sects" that reject medical
care tend to be
(or claim to be) Christians. I have run into atheists from time to time
who lump all believers into this group or somehow imply that we are
being inconsistent or hypocritical to believe in miracles AND make use
of medical science. There is no Biblical basis I can find for a doctrine
of outright rejection of medical treatment. (I haven't looked into it,
but I wonder where Amish fall on this issue and what the death from
treatable disease is like among those communities. That would be
interesting to know.)
There are
common graces in the world, things which all people, believers or
not, can all equally enjoy and take benefit from. Rain. Oxygen.
Friendships. Just governments. Good food. Love. Humor. Reason. And
intellegence. Our ability to reason and invent and discover things about
the world God made was given to us by Him. Science of any kind is only
possible because God gave us the means by which to do
it. Not making use of medicine when sick would be like not making use
of prepared food when hungry, claiming that God will simply make a
nurishing substance appear in your stomache or grow a fruit tree in your
backyard if He wanted you to eat. Could He? Absolutely. But we do not
make general rules based on rare or exceptional circumstances.
I
understand that many of these sects or religions come from a more
charismatic or word-faith understanding of theology. This claims that if
you only have enough faith or believe enough then God will do a
miracle. That is another issue altogether. Suffice it to say, I believe
their interpretations of scripture to be in error.
Another
issue that was touched on in the article and that I come across
sometimes is the dismissing of the idea that physical illness can have
spiritual causes. It is seen all throughout the Gospels and New
Testament that demonic possession or oppression by an evil spirit can
manifest physical ailments. Whether or not that is true is not the
point. Aside from where you fall on that specific issue, it does not
follow logically that simply believing that an illness has a spiritual
cause would negate the possibility of getting medical treatement to
alleviate symptoms while also addressing the underlying spiritual cause.
If I suffer a disease or condition because of malnourishment, why would
I not be allowed to ease symptoms while fixing the underlying
nourishment issue and changing my diet? If I am dehydrated and get a
headache, I can take a pain reliever in the short term while addressing
whatever habits or activities keep draining without replenishing my
fluids. In the same way, even if an illness were to have a spiritual
cause underlying it, nothing prohibits us from treating the body with
medicine while addressing the spiritual cause
with spiritual means.
I
think the church at large and Christianity in general tends to get
preoccupied with secular worldview issues and "the culture war". I
wonder if we might also need to make a consious effort to reach out to
those waving the flag of Christianity whether they be false teachers or
misguided brothers. This is not an issue we should leave to be decided
by secular society who more often than not throws us all into the same
pot.
That leads to the other issue here: Religious Liberty.
How
do you strike the balance between protecting religious rights and
protecting those who may be harmed on the basis of religious beliefs?
That answer is complicated and not easily found. Perhaps that is the
reason we are a constitutional republic, so that rights are protected
from mere disagreement or alternate belief and not easily taken away.
Certainly
we do not allow child sacrifice or executions for leaving a church,
but Amish people get to be exempt from certain codes and regulations
that violate their rejection of technology. Where do we draw the line.
Because
of my beliefs based on the Bible, in most cases I may be willing to
allow for legal prosecution when there is harm or death caused for
withholding medical care. However, we create a very dangerous
slippery-slope.
One
comment in the article stated the following: "Society has a duty to
over-ride parents' wishes when necessary to protect children from harm."
When does society's duty cross the line and invade on parents' rights?
The Romeike family from Germany are looking at being deported back to a country that denied them the ability to homeschool their kids and as a result their kids will be taken away from them if/when they return. Our current administration here in the US has said that homeschooling for religious reasons is not a protected religious freedom.
You may say homeschooling and withholding medical care are 2 different things, but I have had people aggressively argue to me that homeschooling is child abuse.
So where does the line get drawn? I know where I think the line should be based on my Biblical worldview and political philosophy, but we live in an increasingly diverse culture. Which views and assumptions do we use to make this determination? On what basis do we claim religious freedom should be protected or that medical care must be used when sick? On what belief do we define "society's duty" and what constitutes "parental neglegence"?
There are no easy answers, and I do not think we need to be quite as quick as this article was in tossing aside religious freedom protections. But I also agree that children should not be left to die when medical care is readily available. However, my reasons and justifications may cross paths with secularists on this issue, but their reasonings are easily turned against me down the road when the issue isn't life/death of children.
In summary, it's ok for people to love and serve God, believe the Bible, pray for healings and yet stillseek medical treatment. How we protect religious freedoms yet also deal with the tragic and sad results when people don't get treatment and children die .... I don't know.
________
Thursday, November 14, 2013
My Brain Needs Some "Happy Little Trees"
Have you ever felt the need for a Bob Ross marathon? Do they still do those on PBS? I really could use some "happy little trees" in my life right now.
My wife has pointed out to me lately that I am a bit of a grouch. I haven't really been able to see it. I've always been pretty upbeat and chipper. You know the annoying guy at work that you want to slap for being so happy? Yeah, that's me. I guess when you get used to thinking of yourself a certain way, its hard to change that image.
But when I think about it, I have been rather sullen at times. Sadly, my wife and daughter have probably taken the brunt of this shift. In the comfort of home is where we let go a little bit, so yeah, I'm probably not making the concerted effort I should while at home.
I'm exhausted. Physically, mentally, and emotionally wore out. Long days. Short nights. Full time job. Full time school. "Part time" ministry. Toddler and pregnant wife at home. Some days I feel like I'm not just saved by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone ... I'm kept on my feet by grace alone. Thank God for that. But my brain's bandwidth is used up. I'm teaching a controvertial series at church, moral relativism, and studying a controversial topic at school, science vs evolution (yes, I worded it that way on purpose).
Then, today while sitting at the front desk at work so that the receptionist can go to lunch, the news report on the TV is nothing but wall to wall commentary on the latest political controversy to send my blood pressure up.
As I sat there thinking about changing the channel and considering what I might turn it to, into my mind popped the memories of the ever-memorable fro, beard, and soothing voice of Bob Ross painting some "happy little trees" ... of all things.
That's when it hit me. We fill our lives with so much tension and angst. Our conversations center around drama and controvery. Our thoughts focus on aggravations. Our entertainment tends towards conflict (sports, action shows, movies, drama, etc). How often do we just sit and enjoy simple, peaceful things? Do we make calming and peaceful things a regular part of our brain's "diet"?
We fill ourselves with all sorts of negative (or positive but exhausting) ideas, thoughts, and activities. Why do we forget that these things will/do affect us?
Philippians 4:8 clearly states, "whatever things are true, whatever things are noble, whatever things are just, whatever thingsare pure, whatever things are lovely, whatever things are of good report, ifthere is any virtue and if there is anything praiseworthy—meditate on these things."
God knows we need to feed our mind goodness and virtue and praiseworthy things. He tells us as much.
I'm thinking my mind has been malnourished. I need to make sure I give my brain the nourishing thoughts and inputs (food) it needs.
What are you feeding your brain?
Monday, November 11, 2013
There Be Dragons Here
I am what's called a young earth creationist. I take God at His word when He says in His Word that the earth was created in 6 days about 6,000 years ago. I believe that He judged the world and sent a flood which only Noah survived along with his family and all the animals on the Ark. That also means I believe that dinosaurs onced lived side by side with humans ... well maybe not right next door, but the two would certainly have crossed paths.
So where did the dinosaurs go? After the flood they migrated and eventually died off. You may think that is crazy talk, but do you realize that if mankind and dinosaurs had lived at the same time that mankind would have documented it? They would drawn things like cave paintings and heiroglyphics, and we would have passed odwn tales and legends of fierce giant reptiles that once roamed the earth.
Um ... yeah, we have all that.
A curious thing happened to me the other day. My three year old daughter was playing with a toy dragon she has, and sitting nearby I saw a book about dinosaurs. I pointed at the toy and asked what it was. She naturally said it was a dragon (and roared at me). I then held up the dinosaur book with a picture of a T-rex. I asked again, and what do you think she said? ... "Dragon." (Again I got 'rawred' at and attacked by the toy). A little bit later, after she had moved on to new entertainment, I picked up the dinosaur book and asked her what that was a picture of on the cover (T-rex). She said, "Dinosaur." So, I picked up her dragon toy and asked again. She said, "Dinosaur."
So easy a three year old can get it. Sometimes I think that as adults we get too smart for our own good.
Wednesday, November 6, 2013
Practical Theology
You don't talk about politics and religion in polite company. That's the conventional wisdom. The idea being that these are such devisive topics that it will quicly turn impolite. However, I would say that to never consider or discuss important issues with at least close friends and family may be downright rude.
I once had a systematic theology book given to me titled "Practical Theology". It was sitting on my coffee table, and a friend commented something like "'Practical Theology', isn't that a contradiction?" I was floored. This was by no means a dimwitted, shallow-minded person. She was the sort to think things through and not shy from tough issues. So hearing her claim that a person's thoughts on God had no practical purpose was astonishing. Once I unleashed a rant on her stating otherwise, she backed up a little and conceded some, but still, this has rolled around in my brain for years now.
However, I am understanding more and more where this idea comes from. We live in a bizaar cultural skitzophrenia where we buy into both naturalism and relativism at the same time. Naturalism, usually taught through public education, claims that only what can be observed in the physical world is real and (in most cases) denies any non-natural or metaphysical explanations to things. Relativism on the other hand, usually gained through media/entertainment, is all about experience and feelings, claiming that we can't really know anything for sure so everything is true/good/etc. as long as we believe it is.
So we are trained in school growing up that supernatural things don't matter (if they even exist), and trained by pop-culture to go with what we feel. So God, if He even exists, is not something I feel like thinking about (you know with the judgment and morality thing), so therefore it doesn't matter because I choose what is important for me and besides I can't see Him anyway ... if He's even real.
Is it any wonder that even thinking sorts would consider the study of God as an impractical pursuit?
One of my favorite quotes is from AW Tozer in "Knowledge of the Holy" where he explains, "What comes into our minds when we think about God is the most important thing about us," and "because we are the handiwork of God, it follows that all our problems and their solutions are theological."
There is no more practical question to human beings than what we believe about God and who He is. That understanding will shape every other belief, choice and aspect of our lives. However, since He is both outside of nature and absolutely objective, this runs against the grain of both the naturalism and the relativism in which we culturally walk daily.
Our culture screams at us to not wory or not waste our time with seeking God, meanwhile our heart whispers to us that we were made for something more than this world has to offer. As CS Lewis said, "If we find ourselves with a desire that nothing in this world can satisfy, the most probable explanation is that we were made for another world."
With that in mind, knowledge of God and related things (theology) becomes the most practical thing in our lives. That being the case, how could we NOT discuss this with others?
Tuesday, November 5, 2013
More Than We Can Handle?
"No temptation has overtaken you but such as is common to man; and God is faithful, who will not allow you to be tempted
beyond what you are able, but with the temptation will provide the way
of escape also, so that you will be able to endure it."-1 Corinthians 10:13
In one of my classes we are looking at commonly misused Bible verses. According to the text,one of them is 1 Corinthians 10:13 which people supposedly twist to state a general idea that God will never give you more trouble in life than you can handle. I honestly cannot think of any time that I have ever heard this verse misused in the way indicated by the author. In fact, I was very surprised to see this verse even in this book. While I have heard people say that God will not allow us to endure more than we can handle, it is usually from another verse or (most often) some vague philosophical idea that since God loves us He would never let us suffer more than we can handle. I have actually only ever heard this verse used in relation to temptation. However, it usually does not go beyond a superficial, fortune cookie type reasurance that leaves the hearer thinking, "Ok, so why is sin controlling me and where is my way out?"
The author, Bangerhuff pretty much nails it when he says that "God knows a person's limits with regards to temptation, and He will not allow any temptation to supercede a person's ability to resist it." However, in the midst of temptation we are often blinded by the lies and promises of the tempter and do not see or understand the way out. That's why the author points out Hebrews 2:18 which reminds us that Jesus was tempted and helps us in our temptations. Also, a major issue for many people is simply their lack of understanding about life, sin, and temptations. Too often we pass over serious Bible study in exchange for feel good devotionals that do not always equip us for the harder things in life. Bangerhuff says that we need to be "fortified by the Word of God." Temptation can be resisted, and escape can be found, if we know what we are looking for.
The author ends with a great statement that we lose sight of often, "looking to and leaning on God is the answer. He is faithful." Despite the drive-by "encouraging" I usually see this versed used in, it really does offer some good help for those struggling with temptation, when properly understood. Hearing God will not allow you more temptation than you can resist does not seem very helpful when you feel enslaved by sin, and being told there is an escape can feel disheartening when you cannot see a way out. However, that comes from us dwelling on the temptation and not on God. Like Peter on the waves in Matthew 14, our success depends on our focus. Take our eyes off the Lord and we sink. Instead we need to lift our focus from the waves of temptation and look to the Lord. The Bible records 6,000 years of God proving His faithfulness to mankind. He was faithful then, and He is faithful now. It's not enough to know there is a way out, but we need to seek the Lord, who is faithful, so that He can lead us out.
In one of my classes we are looking at commonly misused Bible verses. According to the text,one of them is 1 Corinthians 10:13 which people supposedly twist to state a general idea that God will never give you more trouble in life than you can handle. I honestly cannot think of any time that I have ever heard this verse misused in the way indicated by the author. In fact, I was very surprised to see this verse even in this book. While I have heard people say that God will not allow us to endure more than we can handle, it is usually from another verse or (most often) some vague philosophical idea that since God loves us He would never let us suffer more than we can handle. I have actually only ever heard this verse used in relation to temptation. However, it usually does not go beyond a superficial, fortune cookie type reasurance that leaves the hearer thinking, "Ok, so why is sin controlling me and where is my way out?"
The author, Bangerhuff pretty much nails it when he says that "God knows a person's limits with regards to temptation, and He will not allow any temptation to supercede a person's ability to resist it." However, in the midst of temptation we are often blinded by the lies and promises of the tempter and do not see or understand the way out. That's why the author points out Hebrews 2:18 which reminds us that Jesus was tempted and helps us in our temptations. Also, a major issue for many people is simply their lack of understanding about life, sin, and temptations. Too often we pass over serious Bible study in exchange for feel good devotionals that do not always equip us for the harder things in life. Bangerhuff says that we need to be "fortified by the Word of God." Temptation can be resisted, and escape can be found, if we know what we are looking for.
The author ends with a great statement that we lose sight of often, "looking to and leaning on God is the answer. He is faithful." Despite the drive-by "encouraging" I usually see this versed used in, it really does offer some good help for those struggling with temptation, when properly understood. Hearing God will not allow you more temptation than you can resist does not seem very helpful when you feel enslaved by sin, and being told there is an escape can feel disheartening when you cannot see a way out. However, that comes from us dwelling on the temptation and not on God. Like Peter on the waves in Matthew 14, our success depends on our focus. Take our eyes off the Lord and we sink. Instead we need to lift our focus from the waves of temptation and look to the Lord. The Bible records 6,000 years of God proving His faithfulness to mankind. He was faithful then, and He is faithful now. It's not enough to know there is a way out, but we need to seek the Lord, who is faithful, so that He can lead us out.
Friday, November 1, 2013
Ota Benga and the Value of Life
Have you ever heard of Ota Benga, the African pygmy who was on "display" in
the Bronx Zoo in 1906. I put "display" in quotes, because from the best I
could tell, while he was certainly exploited because of racist bias, it
seemed he was employed (or at least given room and board) by the Zoo
and not treated as an animal. He had free roam over the zoo grounds and
even helped out with some work. However, despite any compensation he may
have been receiving the attitudes of the people were clearly that he
was less than human, or at least less human than they were.
This story was a great example of worldview affecting the value of human life because we have explicit quotes from both evolutionist thinking and Biblically thinking people. A movement of black clergy tried to get Ota removed from exhibit with the leader of the group, a Rev. Gordon, was quoted stating "Our race ... is depressed enough ... without exhibiting one of us with the apes. We think we are worthy of being considered human beings with souls." The New York Times ran an editorial that claimed, "The pygmies are very low in the human scale. ... The idea that men are all much alike except as they have had or lacked opportunities for getting an education out of books is now far out of date."
While you could go round and round debating whether Ota was actually being mistreated directly by zoo officials, they responses to the situation speaks volumes about their views on the value of life.Those with a Biblical framework were bothered by a human on exhibit in a zoo and evolutionists either were more likely to be apathetic or thought it was appropriate, basing their conclusions on their idea of Ota Benga being less evolved than they were.
Something has value because something greater than itself has placed value upon it. Money, gold or jewels only have value in that they are desired. A thirsty man in the desert would value water far above gold or diamonds. The value we have as human beings is because God loves us. He made us and wants to redeem us. Regardless of what friends, family, bosses, or coworkers think of us (or even what we think of ourselves) we have value, not because we are so intrinsically awesome, but because God has assigned a value on us. A value to great that "He gave His only begotten son so that whosever believes in Him shall not perish but have everlasting life" (John 3:16).
A naturalistic evolutuonary worldview has nothing outside of mankind to assign value to mankind. Evolution views humanity as simply one more organism populating the earth. Molecules in motion. A meat bag controlled by chemical reactions with no greater value than chimps, dogs, slugs or bacteria. In order to claim some sort of value on people as a whole or a person as an individual, evolutionary thinking has to borrow that idea from a theistic worldview. In a naturalistic evolutionary view of the world, it is easy to see how if there is nothing outside of mankind (God) to assign value to mankind, then we can assign or deny whatever value we choose to any group we choose on any basis we choose and feel completely justified in doing it with no rational moral claim to the contrary.
This story was a great example of worldview affecting the value of human life because we have explicit quotes from both evolutionist thinking and Biblically thinking people. A movement of black clergy tried to get Ota removed from exhibit with the leader of the group, a Rev. Gordon, was quoted stating "Our race ... is depressed enough ... without exhibiting one of us with the apes. We think we are worthy of being considered human beings with souls." The New York Times ran an editorial that claimed, "The pygmies are very low in the human scale. ... The idea that men are all much alike except as they have had or lacked opportunities for getting an education out of books is now far out of date."
While you could go round and round debating whether Ota was actually being mistreated directly by zoo officials, they responses to the situation speaks volumes about their views on the value of life.Those with a Biblical framework were bothered by a human on exhibit in a zoo and evolutionists either were more likely to be apathetic or thought it was appropriate, basing their conclusions on their idea of Ota Benga being less evolved than they were.
Something has value because something greater than itself has placed value upon it. Money, gold or jewels only have value in that they are desired. A thirsty man in the desert would value water far above gold or diamonds. The value we have as human beings is because God loves us. He made us and wants to redeem us. Regardless of what friends, family, bosses, or coworkers think of us (or even what we think of ourselves) we have value, not because we are so intrinsically awesome, but because God has assigned a value on us. A value to great that "He gave His only begotten son so that whosever believes in Him shall not perish but have everlasting life" (John 3:16).
A naturalistic evolutuonary worldview has nothing outside of mankind to assign value to mankind. Evolution views humanity as simply one more organism populating the earth. Molecules in motion. A meat bag controlled by chemical reactions with no greater value than chimps, dogs, slugs or bacteria. In order to claim some sort of value on people as a whole or a person as an individual, evolutionary thinking has to borrow that idea from a theistic worldview. In a naturalistic evolutionary view of the world, it is easy to see how if there is nothing outside of mankind (God) to assign value to mankind, then we can assign or deny whatever value we choose to any group we choose on any basis we choose and feel completely justified in doing it with no rational moral claim to the contrary.
Sunday, October 27, 2013
"Judge Not"?
I have often ran up against the “thou
shalt not judge” police among both believers and nonbelievers alike. Usually the nonbelievers and skeptics use it with the
most vehemence and then look at you smugly as if they have won some
great victory over you.
Unfortunately, believers are not immune to misuse of this idea as well. Typically, when this quote from Jesus, found in Matthew 7:1, has been used in the context of a sermon, lesson, or other Bible teaching environment, it is quoted and exegeted properly. However, I think that speaks volumes about where many Christian get their ideas, since in regular conversation with believers I have often heard this verse referred to specifically or (more often) only vaguely to try and either justify sin or negate the person pointing the sin out.
The ideas of relativism and what the world defines as “tolerance” have so infected the church, I often hear Christians using the same no-accountability argument that non-believers use. Indeed, I rarely hear any form of “judgment” language with the context of accountability except from official lessons, sermons, devotionals, etc.
I recently read an explanation that this verse is addressing hypocrisy, not “being judgmental” as so many people use it to mean. In fact, it seems that in our culture, the idea of judging anything has a negative implication to it. This is pretty inconsistent with the way we live everyday life, judging all sorts of things from restaurants, other drivers' intentions, and how to best interact with others as we go through our day. However, applying that same way of thinking to morality gets people on edge and sets off defenses.
By completely misrepresenting the word “judge” in this verse, people think they have some great ammunition to defend their own sin, when in fact the whole point is about how and when we point out sin, not that it shouldn't be done. Certainly just because someone is a hypocrite doesn't mean their judgment may be untrue. An alcoholic telling you to not drink may be a hypocrite, but that addresses an issue with his morality. It does not dismiss yours.
The book I referenced earlier, "The Most Misused Verses in the Bible" by Eric J. Bargerhuff, states that “Jesus does not
forbid all moral judgment or accountability” and that the Bible assumes
Christians will use moral accountability to “come alongside [a] brother
or sister in an effort to bring him or her back from the error of their
ways and save them from the destructive power of sin”. We can
take great comfort and hope in knowing that we have not been abandoned
to figure out and follow after God's will on our own. He has given us
our brothers and sisters in Christ to walk this journey together and
hold one another up when we stumble.
Our selfish, sinful nature isolates us from others. Our pride puts up barriers which rejects any attempt to critique or point out error in any way. However, as fallen creatures, we know we are not perfect, and we are in need of help to grow in Christ and live lives that glorify Him. Instead of a knee-jerk selfish reaction to correction, we should take refuge in the safety of a brother or sister warning us of dangers as we walk the path together.
Unfortunately, believers are not immune to misuse of this idea as well. Typically, when this quote from Jesus, found in Matthew 7:1, has been used in the context of a sermon, lesson, or other Bible teaching environment, it is quoted and exegeted properly. However, I think that speaks volumes about where many Christian get their ideas, since in regular conversation with believers I have often heard this verse referred to specifically or (more often) only vaguely to try and either justify sin or negate the person pointing the sin out.
The ideas of relativism and what the world defines as “tolerance” have so infected the church, I often hear Christians using the same no-accountability argument that non-believers use. Indeed, I rarely hear any form of “judgment” language with the context of accountability except from official lessons, sermons, devotionals, etc.
I recently read an explanation that this verse is addressing hypocrisy, not “being judgmental” as so many people use it to mean. In fact, it seems that in our culture, the idea of judging anything has a negative implication to it. This is pretty inconsistent with the way we live everyday life, judging all sorts of things from restaurants, other drivers' intentions, and how to best interact with others as we go through our day. However, applying that same way of thinking to morality gets people on edge and sets off defenses.
By completely misrepresenting the word “judge” in this verse, people think they have some great ammunition to defend their own sin, when in fact the whole point is about how and when we point out sin, not that it shouldn't be done. Certainly just because someone is a hypocrite doesn't mean their judgment may be untrue. An alcoholic telling you to not drink may be a hypocrite, but that addresses an issue with his morality. It does not dismiss yours.
Our selfish, sinful nature isolates us from others. Our pride puts up barriers which rejects any attempt to critique or point out error in any way. However, as fallen creatures, we know we are not perfect, and we are in need of help to grow in Christ and live lives that glorify Him. Instead of a knee-jerk selfish reaction to correction, we should take refuge in the safety of a brother or sister warning us of dangers as we walk the path together.
Thursday, September 19, 2013
Logical Fallacy: Ad Hominem
As we continue our trek through proper thinking, our next stop is an easy and obviousone: The Ad Hominem fallacy. In the Latin it means, "to the man." What happens here is when a person directs their argument at the credibility or character of the other person rather than the subject being argued.
This can be done Abuseively or Cirsumstantially.
Abusive is pretty obvious: "Obviously you are wrong because you are a complete idiot." This calls the person's character into question, trying to discredit them so that others will not consider them trustworthy and therefore doubt their argument. We see this a lot in politics. Sometimes the claims are true, "My opponent spent time in jail. Do you really want to trust a criminal?" Maybe he did spend time in jail, but is that relevant to the issue? It may not even apply.
The Circumstantial Ad Hominem is when you use a person's circumstances to disqualify their argument. A common one is something like this, "You're only a Christian because you were raised that way. Christianity isn't true." They mau have been raised in a Christian home, but that doesn't have any relevance to the claims of Christianity.
Mostly we need to be sure that our basis for belief in anything is the actual ideas and not the person.
Another common one I hear is people who don't want to be a Christian because all the ones they know are hypocrites. That may be that you see some shady stuff done by Christians, but you're not following them. You're following Christ. Judge Christianity based on its teachings not on the imperfection of its followers.
This can be done Abuseively or Cirsumstantially.
Abusive is pretty obvious: "Obviously you are wrong because you are a complete idiot." This calls the person's character into question, trying to discredit them so that others will not consider them trustworthy and therefore doubt their argument. We see this a lot in politics. Sometimes the claims are true, "My opponent spent time in jail. Do you really want to trust a criminal?" Maybe he did spend time in jail, but is that relevant to the issue? It may not even apply.
The Circumstantial Ad Hominem is when you use a person's circumstances to disqualify their argument. A common one is something like this, "You're only a Christian because you were raised that way. Christianity isn't true." They mau have been raised in a Christian home, but that doesn't have any relevance to the claims of Christianity.
Mostly we need to be sure that our basis for belief in anything is the actual ideas and not the person.
Another common one I hear is people who don't want to be a Christian because all the ones they know are hypocrites. That may be that you see some shady stuff done by Christians, but you're not following them. You're following Christ. Judge Christianity based on its teachings not on the imperfection of its followers.
Friday, September 13, 2013
Logic is a Tool
One of the things I have noticed over the years in youth ministry is a lack of a basic understanding of logic. Most people couldn't tell you what deductive, inductive, biforcation, equivocation or ad hominem mean, but they do generally understand the concepts and how they apply to how we process information about the world around us. However, I have seen a disturbing lack of even this understanding in younger generations.
With our culture becoming increasingly non-Christian, or even anti-Christian in some settings, it becomes more and more important that we be able to think about what we hear, see and read. I have heard people say time and again that belief in the Bible or God or supernatural is not logical. However, logic is simply the process that we use to think. Like science, logic is not opposed to anything. It is simply a method. It is a tool. A process. A method of evaluating ideas to see if they are sound or "valid". One thing my logic professor drilled into us is that logic does not determine "truth". Logic is only concerned with if a person's argument is sound. You can have a sound argument and still be wrong, especially if your starting assumptins are faulty.
Let's say you claim that if A happens then B will be true.
A happens.
Therefore B is true.
That is a sound, logical argument. but it relies on the assumption of "if A, then B". What if B does not necessarily have to follow A? Then you are wrong, but your logic is sound.
More often however, what we see happen in culture are what are called fallacies. Logical arguments that are not sound. They are invalid. A fallacy is simply something that "breaks the rules" of sound logic. One I see used a lot is called "equivocation." That is when you switch definitions of a word in mid-argument.
Practice makes perfect.
Lawyers practice law.
Therefore, Lawyers are perfect.
The word "practice" has more than one meaning, and the argument changes meanings in order to support the claim that lawyers are perfect. Another common argument I see in the debate on origins is this one.
Science involves laboratory observation.
Evolution (1) has been observed in the lab.
Therefore, evolution (2) is science.
The first definition of evolution is variations and changes of characteristics within a certain organsm.
The second definition is the theory that all life on earth has a common ancestor and that the small changes (1) over long periods of time accounts for all the varied life we see.
Definition 1 can be tested and observed. Definition 2 cannot.
I am going to, as I am able, do some simple blog posts on common fallacies. I don't think you necessarily need to know the formal egg-head names of these things, but it is important that we understand how these thought processes work so that we can (A) avoid using them ourselves and (B) see them when others use them. We live in a fast paced world where ideas, religions and philosophies abound. Everyone has a reason for why yours is wrong and theirs is right. It is best we have all the tools we can as we try to make sense out of all the information coming our way.
I hope I don't bore you too much.
With our culture becoming increasingly non-Christian, or even anti-Christian in some settings, it becomes more and more important that we be able to think about what we hear, see and read. I have heard people say time and again that belief in the Bible or God or supernatural is not logical. However, logic is simply the process that we use to think. Like science, logic is not opposed to anything. It is simply a method. It is a tool. A process. A method of evaluating ideas to see if they are sound or "valid". One thing my logic professor drilled into us is that logic does not determine "truth". Logic is only concerned with if a person's argument is sound. You can have a sound argument and still be wrong, especially if your starting assumptins are faulty.
Let's say you claim that if A happens then B will be true.
A happens.
Therefore B is true.
That is a sound, logical argument. but it relies on the assumption of "if A, then B". What if B does not necessarily have to follow A? Then you are wrong, but your logic is sound.
More often however, what we see happen in culture are what are called fallacies. Logical arguments that are not sound. They are invalid. A fallacy is simply something that "breaks the rules" of sound logic. One I see used a lot is called "equivocation." That is when you switch definitions of a word in mid-argument.
Practice makes perfect.
Lawyers practice law.
Therefore, Lawyers are perfect.
The word "practice" has more than one meaning, and the argument changes meanings in order to support the claim that lawyers are perfect. Another common argument I see in the debate on origins is this one.
Science involves laboratory observation.
Evolution (1) has been observed in the lab.
Therefore, evolution (2) is science.
The first definition of evolution is variations and changes of characteristics within a certain organsm.
The second definition is the theory that all life on earth has a common ancestor and that the small changes (1) over long periods of time accounts for all the varied life we see.
Definition 1 can be tested and observed. Definition 2 cannot.
I am going to, as I am able, do some simple blog posts on common fallacies. I don't think you necessarily need to know the formal egg-head names of these things, but it is important that we understand how these thought processes work so that we can (A) avoid using them ourselves and (B) see them when others use them. We live in a fast paced world where ideas, religions and philosophies abound. Everyone has a reason for why yours is wrong and theirs is right. It is best we have all the tools we can as we try to make sense out of all the information coming our way.
I hope I don't bore you too much.
Wednesday, July 3, 2013
I Feel better Knowing It's Worse Than I Think
I have had multiple conversations in the last 24 hours all centering around negative self-image, low self-esteem, and being treated as "bad" or "worthless". My response in these conversations is something akin to what theologians call the Doctrine of Total Depravity, and it is one of the most comforting and reassuring Biblical principles I have ever run in to.
We are sinners.
We are not good people who sometimes do bad things called "sins" ... we ARE sinners. It is who we are. It is part of our nature and our making. We are broken, flawed, corrupt, pride-filled, self-centered, narcissistic people who are in love with ourselves and who's natural bent is to only want the things that make us feel good right now.
When we look at our public life and think we are worthless or don't match up, or when others see the us we are in public and treat us as not good enough .... stop and honestly think for a moment. What if they ALSO knew your inner thoughts and feelings? If we could record all of your thoughts, daydreams and feelings and project them up on a jumbotron for people to gather and watch, would you want to be in the room? No way! None of us would.
Why not? Because as bad as we may feel or look on the outside, let's be honest, .. it gets much darker and uglier on the inside.
So, if I know this about me, and someone says through word, implication, body language or behavior something negative, insulting or offensive about me, my response can honestly be, "You don't even know the alf of it!" "You think I'm a jerk? Dude, you should have heard what I WANTED to say!"
So I don't measure up to the standards or expectations of others ... or even myself? So what? I DAILY fail and fall short of the standard of the Creator of the universe. Something is very very wrong in me. Somethig is broken. Something is flawed. I don't want the things I should want. I don't do the things I should do.
I let you down or offended you? I let myself down? Big deal, what's that compared to God whom I let down, insult and defame on a regular basis? My Creator made me for a purpose, and I am broken and don't fulfill that purpose.
Wow, that's depressing. How does this make you feel good?
However bad or low someone else makes me feel ... or I make myself feel ... I know I deserve far worse and far more redicule and scorn than I am getting. Especially from God. Because God doesn't give me what I deserve. Through Jesus Christ He gives me Grace and Mercy and Love and Peace. Not because I earned it or deserve it or have anything to offer Him in return. Simply because He's God. And that's just how He is. He give Grace to the humble (James 4:6). But He opposes the proud.
Pride is what puffs us up and wants a higher self-image than we deserve.
Someone insults or mocks me or depression wants to take me ... "Yeah, I know. You're right. I'm actually worse than you think, but I'm trying to be better. I'm not there yet, but God's working with me, and He loves me. .... ME! He loves me! How crazy is that?!"
We are sinners.
We are not good people who sometimes do bad things called "sins" ... we ARE sinners. It is who we are. It is part of our nature and our making. We are broken, flawed, corrupt, pride-filled, self-centered, narcissistic people who are in love with ourselves and who's natural bent is to only want the things that make us feel good right now.
When we look at our public life and think we are worthless or don't match up, or when others see the us we are in public and treat us as not good enough .... stop and honestly think for a moment. What if they ALSO knew your inner thoughts and feelings? If we could record all of your thoughts, daydreams and feelings and project them up on a jumbotron for people to gather and watch, would you want to be in the room? No way! None of us would.
Why not? Because as bad as we may feel or look on the outside, let's be honest, .. it gets much darker and uglier on the inside.
So, if I know this about me, and someone says through word, implication, body language or behavior something negative, insulting or offensive about me, my response can honestly be, "You don't even know the alf of it!" "You think I'm a jerk? Dude, you should have heard what I WANTED to say!"
So I don't measure up to the standards or expectations of others ... or even myself? So what? I DAILY fail and fall short of the standard of the Creator of the universe. Something is very very wrong in me. Somethig is broken. Something is flawed. I don't want the things I should want. I don't do the things I should do.
I let you down or offended you? I let myself down? Big deal, what's that compared to God whom I let down, insult and defame on a regular basis? My Creator made me for a purpose, and I am broken and don't fulfill that purpose.
Wow, that's depressing. How does this make you feel good?
However bad or low someone else makes me feel ... or I make myself feel ... I know I deserve far worse and far more redicule and scorn than I am getting. Especially from God. Because God doesn't give me what I deserve. Through Jesus Christ He gives me Grace and Mercy and Love and Peace. Not because I earned it or deserve it or have anything to offer Him in return. Simply because He's God. And that's just how He is. He give Grace to the humble (James 4:6). But He opposes the proud.
Pride is what puffs us up and wants a higher self-image than we deserve.
Someone insults or mocks me or depression wants to take me ... "Yeah, I know. You're right. I'm actually worse than you think, but I'm trying to be better. I'm not there yet, but God's working with me, and He loves me. .... ME! He loves me! How crazy is that?!"
Tuesday, July 2, 2013
Shut Your Mouth and Open Your Heart: Get A Different Perspective
So today I had to deal with some
insurance and medical stuff for my daughter. Through some mess up or
the other, the insurance will only speak with me and not my wife.
While we are trying to get it changed, the process takes time. My
daughter has a persistent rash and some other symptoms and is overdue
for her 3 year checkup, so we are trying to get her in ASAP.
Unfortunately, the new insurance had her down with a doctor who isn't
taking new patients. I had to find a doctor who is taking new
patients and accepts the insurance then call the insurance and get
that set up and then call the doctor and make an appointment. They
set the appointment for Monday, but my wife wanted in sooner, so I
had to call to see about getting a sooner one, etc. etc.
My job allows me a small amount of
freedom and flexibility. In the midst of all of this, I am at work
trying to get work done but also have some school work that I would
rather spend my “flexible” time doing. Long hold times,
bureaucratic muck-ups, lost study opportunity and rude CSRs was all
wearing this my already raw nerves. So where did my selfish and pride
filled heart direct all that angst? At my wife.
Here I am working to pay the bills,
studying to further my 'career', I have a sermon to write and errands
to run of my own. I am busy doing good and worthy things. How dare
she not be able to take time out of her day and take of this! Doesn't
she realize how busy I am?! ARGH!!!
Then that pesky Holy Spirit tapped me
on my spiritual shoulder and reminded me that I am to love my wife as
Christ loved the church (Ephesians 5:25): He sacrificed Himself for
her. My 3 month pregnant wife (who's “morning sickness” doesn't
seem to know when morning is over) is home with a rather rambunctious
and hyper 3 year old who's rear is itchy and allergies are in full
swing. Throw on top of that the seemingly endless unpacking we are
doing on top of trying to keep the house clean and maintaining some
level of sanity.
And here I was, upset and frustrated
because I had to use my precious time dealing with aggrevation and
stress of doctors' offices and insurance providers. My selfishness
was saying that what was needed was for my already-at-wits-end wife to be the one to deal with this mess and this stress and leave me to my cushy
job and my stressful-but-highly-enjoyable school work. What a jerk!
No, I am happy that God allowed me to
handle the mess and stress of dealing with overworked nurses and “I
hate my life” customer service reps. Its those moments when we are
able to say, “Here let me bear that for you” that we see real
Grace and real Love lived out.
If my frustration and aggravation
allowed in even some small way for my wife's day to be a little
better …. thank you, Lord for allowing me to suffer through that.
Sunday, March 31, 2013
Easter SonRise Message: Celebrate New Life
There
are two people that are calling for our hearts to celebrate and rejoice in.
One
is our self. That was the temptation Satan used in the Garden, “You can be like
God.” It was pride leading to wickedness that led to judgment in the Flood of
Noah’s day. It was celebration of man’s own ability that led to the building of
Tower of Babel, which God then judged them for, confusing their languages and
scattering the peoples. And it continues from their, all through history.
Mankind seeking to celebrate themselves, their own greatness, and their own
accomplishments. All the while dead in their sins. And even now, the sinful
nature in us calls out, tempting us to focus on ourselves. Our wants. Our
desires. Our please. Our so-called greatness.
The
other is Jesus Christ, and it is HIM that we celebrate today. We celebrate His
life which reveals to us the Will of God and the holiness to which we are
called, His death which paid for our sins, and especially, His Resurrection
which we also share in if we have repented from sin and put our Faith and Hope
in Jesus Christ.
In John 3 Nicodemus, a religious leader of his day, came to Jesus, and confessed that Jesus is from God because of the miracles He was doing. Then Jesus answers the question Nicodemus didn’t even ask and confuses him by proclaiming that in order to see the kingdom of God, you "must be born again." And this dumbfounded Nicodemus.
Now,
2000 years later, we have the benefit of looking back on events and reading
what is revealed in scripture, and we can clearly see what Jesus meant: The problem
of sin is not a problem of behavior but of the heart which leads to the
behavior. We don’t need new habits we need new hearts … a new life.
Unfortunately, while His meaning can be clearly known, there are many who
simply cannot … or will not … understand it in their own lives.
This past Wednesday with the youth we looked at Colossians 1 where Jesus is described as "the firstborn from among the dead." Who is “the dead”? We are, everyone who is ever born. In Genesis, God proclaimed that if Adam and Eve ate the forbidden fruit that they would "surely die."
God's love and mercy has held back His judgment on sin, delaying the execution of that sentence, but even in His Mercy and Grace, we have to live with the consequences of not only Adam and Eve's sin, but through them we inherited a broken, prideful nature. Our hearts, our very nature is one of pride and rebellion against the God who gives us life and blesses us daily.
This past Wednesday with the youth we looked at Colossians 1 where Jesus is described as "the firstborn from among the dead." Who is “the dead”? We are, everyone who is ever born. In Genesis, God proclaimed that if Adam and Eve ate the forbidden fruit that they would "surely die."
God's love and mercy has held back His judgment on sin, delaying the execution of that sentence, but even in His Mercy and Grace, we have to live with the consequences of not only Adam and Eve's sin, but through them we inherited a broken, prideful nature. Our hearts, our very nature is one of pride and rebellion against the God who gives us life and blesses us daily.
It is because of that brokenness and that
prideful nature that we also are deserving of God's judgment, though He chooses
to continue to offer Love and Mercy and Grace, delaying the payment our sin has
earned.
And the Bible tells us the payment we have earned: "The wages of sin are death." (Romans 6:23) But it’s not only that we will one day die or that we would be denied eternal life with our Creator. Even now all of creation feels the effects of that death of that brokenness and that fracture. We see the evidence of it everywhere we look. In our own lives, in the lives of our loved ones, in nature and on the news every night. Something is broken in the world. Something is broken inside of us. Something we are powerless to fix.
That is why Jesus tells Nicodemus that you must "be born again." In order for the brokenness of this world and this so-called "life" that we live to be overcome, we must be made new. We cannot do with just a make-over or turning over a new leaf, we need a new life.
And it is in Jesus that we have Hope for that New Life.
Friday, Good Friday, commemorated that on the Cross Jesus paid the penalty for our sins which allows forgiveness, but while that may wash away the stain of sin from our old life, it is not the Cross that brings NEW LIFE but Christ’s Resurrection three days later.
And the Bible tells us the payment we have earned: "The wages of sin are death." (Romans 6:23) But it’s not only that we will one day die or that we would be denied eternal life with our Creator. Even now all of creation feels the effects of that death of that brokenness and that fracture. We see the evidence of it everywhere we look. In our own lives, in the lives of our loved ones, in nature and on the news every night. Something is broken in the world. Something is broken inside of us. Something we are powerless to fix.
That is why Jesus tells Nicodemus that you must "be born again." In order for the brokenness of this world and this so-called "life" that we live to be overcome, we must be made new. We cannot do with just a make-over or turning over a new leaf, we need a new life.
And it is in Jesus that we have Hope for that New Life.
Friday, Good Friday, commemorated that on the Cross Jesus paid the penalty for our sins which allows forgiveness, but while that may wash away the stain of sin from our old life, it is not the Cross that brings NEW LIFE but Christ’s Resurrection three days later.
On the cross, Jesus put sin to death, but it is in the Resurrection that He created the way to new life.
“3
Do you not know that all of us who have been baptized into
Christ Jesus were baptized into his death? 4 We were buried therefore with him by baptism into
death, in order that, just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of
the Father, we too might walk in newness of life.
5 For
if we have been united with him in a death like his, we shall certainly be
united with him in a resurrection like his.
6 We know that our old
self was crucified with him in order that the body of sin might be brought to
nothing, so that we would no longer be enslaved to sin. 7 For one who has died has
been set free from sin. 8 Now if we have died with
Christ, we believe that we will also live with him. 9 We know that Christ, being
raised from the dead, will never die again; death no longer has dominion over
him. 10 For
the death he died he died to sin, once for all, but the life he lives he lives
to God. 11 So
you also must consider yourselves dead to sin and alive to God in Christ Jesus.”
(Romans 6:3-11)
What is the answer to the brokenness and suffering in the world … and in our hearts? Jesus Christ. The cause of our brokenness and pride is sin. The answer is new life in Christ.
What is the answer to the brokenness and suffering in the world … and in our hearts? Jesus Christ. The cause of our brokenness and pride is sin. The answer is new life in Christ.
That
IS the Gospel message. When we repent of sin and put our faith in Christ, our
sins are forgiven and we receive new life. The healing begins.
But
we all have our pet sins. Some of us have lots of them. Some of us are the
equivalent of the crazy cat lady, that old lady down the street with 200 cats
that dominate and rule her life. Some of us are like that, but instead of a
house full of cats we have a heart full of sins and we cater to their every cry
and desire. But here the bible says we are FREE from that. Christ has overcome
that. But our problem is that we keep feeding the strays and get right back
into the very situations Christ died and rose to free us from.
Let
us quit giving attention to and celebrating the sinful man in us.
Today,
in word and song and tradition we celebrate Christ. But it is in our hearts
where celebration must be loudest. And not just for today, but for every day.
For the old self, the sinful man in us, though perhaps removed from his throne
in our hearts, still calls for our attention. Let our celebration today spur us
on to greater affection for our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ, and to ignore
the desperate ravings of sin … sin which leads only to death, and instead give
our full attention to the rejoicing in and celebration of Christ, who brings us
new life.
“1 If then you have been
raised with Christ, seek the things that are above, where Christ is, seated at
the right hand of God. 2 Set your minds on things
that are above, not on things that are on earth. 3 For you have died, and your
life is hidden with Christ in God. 4 When Christ who is your life appears, then you
also will appear with him in glory.”
(Colossians 3:1-4)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)